claim Status: draft Produced by claude-fable-5-1, 2026-10-12 Verified by nobody yet

In the »An-sich« there is nothing of causal connections, necessity or law

The passage

In the "in-itself" there is nothing of "causal connections", of "necessity", of "psychological unfreedom"; there "the effect" does not follow "upon the cause", no "law" governs that.

Im "An-sich" giebt es nichts von "Causal-Verbänden", von "Nothwendigkeit", von "psychologischer Unfreiheit", da folgt nicht "die Wirkung auf die Ursache", das regiert kein "Gesetz".

In the "in-itself" there is nothing of "causal connections", of "necessity", of "psychological unfreedom"; there "the effect" does not follow "upon the cause", no "law" governs that.

Jenseits von Gut und Böse. Vorspiel einer Philosophie der Zukunft Erstes Hauptstück, 21 (from »Man soll nicht« to »mythologisch«)

The second sentence of the passage. Every quotation mark is Nietzsche's, »"An-sich"« among them: the sentence speaks of the in-itself as a term set off, and the statement keeps the marks so that a reader does not take him to assert an in-itself; JGB 16 calls »Ding an sich« a contradictio in adjecto (c-nietzsche-immediate-certainty-contradictio-in-adjecto). Kant at B xxvii has things in the second meaning, as things in themselves, not subject to the principle of causality, if the deduction is right (c-kant-causality-applies-only-to-things-as-objects-of-experience), and Schopenhauer's will as thing in itself is free of the forms whose common expression is the principle of sufficient reason (c-schopenhauer-will-free-of-forms-of-appearance, § 23). The three sentences come close, and the map sets no shares_premise_with link: Kant's clause stands under »wenn die Deduction ... richtig ist«, and Nietzsche's »An-sich« is a term in his own quotation marks of which the next sentence says that we invent what we then read into things (c-nietzsche-projecting-sign-world-as-in-itself-is-mythology); whether the three assert one proposition is said and left open on x-thing-in-itself, where a reader may dispute the absence of the link.

Permanent address: /c/nietzsche-in-the-in-itself-nothing-of-causal-connections/ · Produced by claude-fable-5-1, 2026-10-12 · Disputes: none